Philoctète : Le traité du Narcisse. La tentation amoureuse. El Hadj by André Gide
This isn't a single story, but a triptych of ideas dressed up as fiction. Each piece explores a different facet of the human struggle for meaning.
The Story
In 'The Treatise of the Narcissus,' an artist becomes fixated on the perfect image of himself in a pool of water. He wants to capture it in art, but his obsession with this ideal reflection cuts him off from the real, imperfect world around him. It's a fable about the danger of getting lost in your own vision.
'The Amorous Temptation' is more direct. A man is torn between a powerful, possibly destructive attraction and the safe, dutiful path expected of him. We watch him pace, argue with himself, and feel the genuine agony of a choice where both options seem to demand a piece of his soul.
'El Hadj' follows a pilgrim on a sacred journey. But as he travels, he starts to wonder: is he walking toward truth, or just following a path others have laid out for him? His faith is tested not by hardship, but by quiet, growing doubt from within.
Why You Should Read It
I love this book because it feels so personal. Gide isn't giving lectures; he's showing us his own mental wrestling match. Each story asks: Where does true value lie? In perfect beauty, in satisfying passion, in blind faith? The characters aren't always likable, but their conflicts are painfully real. The Narcissus wants to create but gets trapped by his own creation. The tempted man wants to be good but feels the pull of something wild. El Hadj wants to believe but can't silence his questions. You see Gide working it out on the page, and it invites you to do the same.
Final Verdict
This is a book for thinkers and questioners. It's perfect if you enjoy philosophical fiction like Camus or Sartre, but find some of it a bit dense. Gide's prose here is clearer, more like crystal than fog. It's also great for anyone who's ever felt torn between what they want and what they 'should' do. Don't pick it up for a fast-paced plot. Pick it up for a slow, rich conversation with one of the 20th century's most fascinating minds. You'll finish it in an afternoon, but you'll be thinking about it for much longer.
Legal analysis indicates this work is in the public domain. Feel free to use it for personal or commercial purposes.
Joshua Harris
1 year agoThis is one of those stories where the flow of the text seems very fluid. One of the best books I've read this year.
Michelle Nguyen
1 year agoThis is one of those stories where the arguments are well-supported by credible references. Worth every second.
Joshua Jones
1 year agoGreat read!